Imagine that YOU are the editor of “Defiance,”
creating a film that reflects your own ethics.
How would you choose to portray the scene where the partisans are beating the scout who is spying on their location?
A. The group kills the scout and gets on with their
lives afterwards
B. The group starts to beat him, and then stops
itself before it is too late
C. The group starts to beat the scout, and then
Tuvia stops them
D. The group kills the scout and then can't believe
what it has done
E. The group kills the scout, and when Tuvia walks
by they are angry at him for not stopping them
F. Another alternative
• Why would you portray that scene in the way that
you've chosen? Why did you choose your answer
over the other answers?
• Describe how your choice connects to your own
personal sense of ethics.
In my choice, I would pick: A. The group kills the scout and gets on with their lives afterwards. I would pick this decision because those who are viewing the video need to know what kind of a situation that they were in. The Jewish community had to do what they had to do in order to survive. My ethics is that in a time when my life and existence is being threatened, then I have to do whatever I can in oreder to survive, no matter what that may be.
No comments:
Post a Comment